|
Protect real value of pensions. Government incentives. A Pensions and Growth Alliance Accompanying notes to slides
Exercising Discretion in DB Pensions: Member Activision and how Government can shape trustee decisions to benefit all stakeholders Discretion is the next big thing in DB pensions. As trustees make “informed decisions” to fulfil their fiduciary duties when there are surpluses they will be asking “relevant questions” on risk / benefits for members. Extra discretionary payments can follow for members. There is an upside now which is endgame and attitude changing for members. It also provides tremendous opportunity for Government, so concerned about economic growth, to shape trustee decisions so they work to all stakeholders’ advantage. Torsten Bell loves charts. So we thought he might like a few on the DB pension story. What the charts show:
Pensions and Growth can work in Alliance. For DB discretion exercisers the first question must be, where is the risk-benefit analysis? Concern about “less” is rightly the starting point. For an investment grade sponsor and a scheme funded to gilts plus 50bp what is the chance of less when running a gilt plus 180 bp return strategy? Negligible. Multiple of two largely uncorrelated risks. Should you trade that for the risk of a life insurer not paying up? The risk is negligible but not implausible. Consultants treat buyout as risk free against which all else is inferior. It is no longer true. The Gold Standard lost many carats with Solvency II and Solvency UK easing financial structures; with fundedre-syphoning £40 billion offshore without sufficient capital commitment and the wave of North Americans bringing their book of own originated private credit to town. The single life insurance risk is higher than it is to run-on with sponsor and ring-fenced assets. Numbers should count. And what could you lose - negligible or not? Well nothing with the all scheme backed, super overfunded PPF if inflation is up to 2.5%. Above that, it's trading 2.5% up to the scheme cap (which can be up to 5%) for discretionary payments if inflation is higher. For the deferred there is the 10% haircut: Here Government could usefully restyle and extend PPF. That contrasts with the insurance sector FSCS, no Government guarantee scheme. If it was ever needed it would not work without pain. FSCS has big exposures and no money. It says it may not pay out 100% on buy-in deals. FSCS is no longer an arm of a cosy London club – but has offshore global majors involved. Needs a tough political operator to tell Apollo, Brookfield, Rothesay or L&G how to behave and cover for other life insurers when they all decide it was weak regulators who caused the problem. So what’s at stake: Discretion can be your friend. What discretionary increases are needed so that members are always better off sticking than twisting? Our model does the sums. The one-off payments; the discretionary increase which means members always receive the value of their accrued benefits. For example, if there is a 5% increase now and inflation is 3.5% on average, after 10 years I’m still better off even if the scheme then joined PPF. And if it does not join PPF, I’m 5% better off. Gaming PPF? No, it’s being informed so you can do your fiduciary duty. So what about the discretionary upside. Starting with a scheme funded to gilts plus 50bp and running a return target of gilts plus 2%, there is excellent scope for making discretionary payments and to have plenty of guardrails to avoid major shifts in financial position. That’s the flexibility that a steady stream of Authorised annual payments allows with the HMRC rule changes from April 2027. These payments out can be set at say 1.5% of assets a year. That means that during the plateau, peak oil years of many schemes, where inflation increases and retirements are balanced by permanent leavers, the core asset base remains. Then the surplus value in the scheme starts to accelerate as the scheme really runs off in run on. We have produced a type of flexible model that should be available to all by next April. It brings in the feature of the scheme that consultants simplify and pass over value to insurers – demography. Apart from prudence in numbers married and retirement age assumptions – the key is life expectancy. Forgotten because the risk transfer industry friendly consultants long ago decided life expectancy was an unrewarded risk. In the era of discretion that is simply not true. And it has lead to the great IFoA CMI offshore value syphon. Nothing has been such a benefit to offshore reinsurers as DB schemes using CMI metrics to value liabilities – because the tables have been so overstated for so long. 20% of quoted life insurer operating profits between 2018 – 2023 were down to releases against CMI table assessed liabilities, a leading analyst found. A year is worth 3% of liabilities - no impact on assets - so on £350 billion of deals since 2018 it’s easy to see that around £15 billion benefit seems to have flowed to reinsurers and insurers. That’s prudence for you. In this case prudence appears to be provided by heavily conflicted employees of insurers, life insurers and consultants that benefit from risk transfer transactions. IFoA code stipulates, members must avoid the perception of conflicts. Now, if we had an Actuarial Standards Board there would be somebody to look into it. That value, given time, could flow to members and sponsors. There is no need to guess with run-on – just show the maturity: be ready to wait and see and use discretion. The message to members: Be far more sceptical. Realise that the sector is well known as scrutiny free. Sir John Kingman scathingly noted it in 2018, as Derek Morris had in 2006. Stand back and look at the data. What the charts tell you is that if members ask for a basic discretionary 10% added payment, it is reasonable and fundable. Look at the amount it costs to add 10% against the asset base of £800 million. 0.6% of assets a year in the model here provides the £4.8 million needed for a 10% increase. When payments fall away 15 years hence the scope for higher payments is very clear. A comparable amount can be allocated to sponsors to improve pensions and fund capital expenditure. Depending on the chosen asset allocation there can be scope to increase direct surplus payments to the sponsor as well. If the sponsor runs with a higher return expectations it can expect higher allocation of a surplus. What can be established now from a review of the history of the scheme and the policies now pursued, is the framework for the use of surpluses. It’s worth remembering that the Trust Deed and Rules are not unchangeable revered text. Amendments can be made to address new circumstances and provide for discretion. But there is a negotiation to be held. Members should be clear who is acting for them. Trustees have a major new role. It is not obvious that a sole trustee – even seen as a spokesperson for a professional trustee body - can sensibly negotiate with the sponsor. An immediate conflict challenge. So where does that leave members? Whether the scheme or a life insurer was behind your pension was not of great interest when the best that happens is one or the other pays. Not anymore. You should expect your trustees to put forward plausible proposals to which the sponsor may say “yes” to the exercise of discretion. And be clear you do not see a risk transfer as an upgrade without value being shared. “Member first” solutions are not just about IT systems working, glossy brochures and annual lunches. It involves more in real pension payments. Inflation is the real risk. Why not start a discussion about looking to cover the hit pensions took after 2020. A one off make up payment should be considered of around 20%. The chart makes the point. For schemes and life insurers Government is taking a clear role in setting the rules. It is Government that has set the framework. It should not be squeamish in using its position to shape – no need to mandate – investment and surplus allocation policies. Hence our proposals that schemes and indeed life insurers which meet expectations for investment allocations have benefits and avoid costs Government introduces.
Further, the increased payments to members will be discretionary and not be a hard cost in the P/L for the sponsor covering a lifetime forward. Section 108(b) and (c) of IAS19 covers discretionary payments. It’s your moment Section 108. But what about the life insurers? They need to realise that members and Government are waking up to what’s in their best interests. To keep members on board with BPAs, value sharing as instigated by M&G has to be attractive. For Government to watch their regulators urge trustees to move to life insurers who sell UK gilt holdings makes no sense. It never really did once so much money started disappearing abroad. Regulators can coordinate and rapidly produce better outcomes. Pension Risk Transfers are undertaken because Government regulators are believed to be keeping insurers’ balance sheets strong and that Government is behind your annuity. Fine. But there should be a quid pro quo after you have made life insurers more profitable through easing solvency requirements. No mandation. But if life insurers do not hold across their asset bases a given level of gilts they should pay a levy for access to FSCS. Trustees should be clear about the non-compliance when transferring business. So where does that take us? Discretion spurred by Authorised Payments is a big idea. Members should be motivated to ensure it works for them. There is serious money that can go to you and your former colleagues – but trustees and sponsors and Government and consultants need to know you are on the case. “Member first” is lip service without a trustee commitment to improve your pension and share the value available. Write in: test out what’s going in. Work to have a member nominated trustee keen to be involved. Write to your MP and / or the MP constituency where you worked. Once some companies move on discretion there will be snowball. We have on the website a suite of back up papers and letters than can be sent to sponsors and trustees. So long taken for granted, it’s time for DB scheme members to find a voice – all stakeholders benefit. Think about the recent example of Rolls Royce. Track the logic of our note “I had, I have, I will have”. The letter to members from the Chair is charming and written as if the last decade had not happened. You had as sponsor a UK quoted FTSE10 £100 billion company: A buy-in added PIC (now Athora) as sponsor. You have now lost with the buyout the sponsor, ring-fenced assets and PPF – all for a Bermudan specialist in private credit origination. All just before discretionary payments become more readily available. (Rolls Royce Severs its DB Pension Scheme : Were Better Outcomes Available?) Out of the changed dynamics come great opportunities to align Pension and Growth exist. There is a group no in place pressing for an Alliance of Pensions and Growth (PAGA). There is a rabble of thinkers and specialists who have been trying to cajole the pension sector into producing strategies meeting the inter-related objectives of pensions and growth. John Hamilton, the chair of the Stagecoach trustees, introduced the ethos of the PAGA “Rabble” to Pension Playpen. There will be more to be heard. Meanwhile remember:
Torsten’s charts can head in the right direction. Sound the Bell. “When the charts are this bad – stop drawing them and start trying to change them.” T. Bell 2024
On DB pensions: “Dull is not the same as unimportant”. T. Bell 2024 He now has a blog “Charting the Course”. Perhaps he would like some charts and stories to help bring the messages home. Pensions are for most people, Torsten recognises, on a par with a trip to the gym – a good idea to avoid. What should DB members do to improve performance? They should ask a single “light the blue touch paper and retire immediately” question of trustees and their (former) employer. Very impactful. “Trustees. Have your actuaries provided a TAS300V2.1 P5 paper yet?” Data fireworks. What the maths and governance required will show trustees and members is that: – Run-on beats buyout in risk-benefit analyses. – Agreement to exercise discretion is needed with the sponsor and should be forthcoming. And when Government realises run-on wins it can provide incentives cost-free to ensure more of £1 trillion plus backing DB pension schemes is invested in the UK. A big win for a little member engagement. We’re all chartists now. The charts for Torsten may ring bells - attached. Government should also ask the life insurers with the £350 billion in pensions to trade more UK gilt and productive asset investment for letting insurers continue to market for free Government regulations as providing absolute confidence and access to the FSCS completely secure safety net as primary selling features. And trustees and sponsors on the treadmill in the Torsten pension gym, take inspiration from the little known pension stories of the Gruffalo’s grandparents and Jemima Puddleduck. The Gruffalo’s grandparents got the pension message from little mouse Little mouse has a DB pension and is on a journey to an inflation protected retirement income. On the way little mouse meets a snake, an owl and a fox proposing buyout if little mouse gives them all the money now and never exercises discretion to have more. Little mouse thanks them but can’t stop because of a meeting with the Gruffalo’s grandparents – their favourite recipe is a “class action” against the risk transfer industry. Little mouse is surprised to find the Gruffalo has grandparents living in a big, messy White Hall full of red tape. They tended to be more class than action. But when little mouse said, “I have lots of scheme member friends in your electorate,” bells started ringing and they quickly tidied up. And little mouse kept the money and Ran On 4 Good, investing widely in their wood. So mice, snakes, owls and the Gruffalo family all lived happily ever after. Only fox was a little upset. Jemima Puddleduck – A retelling A month ago: Jemima here. Just wanted to share I started sitting on 9 DB nest eggs today! Has been top secret!! My farmyard friends were so difficult. All those rules and restrictions and taking eggs away. So I made off on my own and met such a lovely gentleman with long whiskers and a bushy tail. He is ever so clever specialising in risk transfer with the Nest Egg Security Alliance. I think he said they provide reinsurance. Anyway, he is really helpful about keeping eggs warm as he has a shed full of comfy feathers. He’s asked me to bring onions and parsnips and the farmer’s purse to get things moving. He said he’ll look after everything after that. Kip Bell: I’m the sheepdog on the farm where Jemima lives. When we saw her post my good foxhound friends led a search party. Pleased to say Jemima is fine and the foxy gentleman has disappeared. We all agreed to Run On 4 Good. Farmer says there’s some wings to be clipped tomorrow. Today: Jemima: I’m delighted to say I will have a healthy clutch of ducklings soon! Run-on Beats Run Away. ------------ Charts and stories: add interest and importance to DB pensions. And DB pensions can add to UK economic growth – not bad. For members : More likely : Downside improbable For Government : A gilt and growth opportunity The Pensions Minister loves charts. Here are three charts central to a powerful risk-benefit exercise. They transform the analysis of the prospects for scheme members and sponsor. They also show DB schemes can add to the Government UK growth story by continuing in the pension sector.
Where’s the pension money gone? More charts. One shows that the longevity tables the pension industry produces led to vast syphoning of resources out of UK. The other shows what regulatory backed derisking programme did to asset allocations. They explain the unfortunate costly economic impact of DB schemes over the last decade. Torsten Bell as a chartist and pensions minister should be taken with them all. Now what? Straight forward corrective actions will help bring growth back to UK: Coordination of regulation; scrutiny and incentives to invest in UK economy long term. And for Government – all hands on deck to protect the UK gilts market. Opportunity for more: Exercising discretion This chart shows a scheme’s assets over time and shows a cumulative amount of surplus paid out. Run-on is itself attractive. Government can make it more attractive to hold more in UK assets. Run-on helps protect the UK gilt market. Chart illustration: This is a £800 million scheme and an actual payment schedule. Investment return of gilts+2% with annual distribution between sponsor and members of 1.5% of assets. A flexible distribution starting at 2% and increasing to 3% from year 20 as pension payments start to fall is shown. The chart shows that even with a significant payment out of surplus assets the scheme continues to generate surplus as it matures. Members can reasonably expect annual discretionary payments adding over 10% to pensions – with higher one-off payments possible. “Informed Decisions” are required of trustees by Government. They now have scope to “exercise discretion”. Have your own model; take your time; phase payments; adjust to investment and demographic scheme experience. Study the variables. Risk of less is negligible Starting with an investment grade sponsor with a scheme at low dependency – the risk is negligible. There are the two largely uncorrelated factors of sponsor collapse and investment strategy failure. The safety nets behind run-on and buyout are PPF – uncorrelated risk and FSCS – correlated sector specific risk (no Government guarantee). PPF has some haircuts but is well funded stop loss: FSCS is a political risk with no stop loss. How much less for a pensioner in PPF: Protecting real pension values The member is interested in “the buying power of a pension”, said Sir Roy Goode even as he advocated inflation caps in 1997. PPF offers protection up to 2.5% per annum. Schemes’ own caps are between 2.5% and 5%. Only the exercise of discretion protects the real value of a pension from spikes – as in the early 2020s. This chart shows how big discretionary increases need to be to eliminate downside. What that means is extra payments, if the scheme does not enter PPF, are all upside. Real inflation risk protection needs to be the focus. Deferred members have a 10% haircut to their pension but good inflation protection while scheme avoids PPF. CMI Longevity Tables – impacts
Asset Allocation Trends of DB Schemes: The triumph of bonds (graphic source PPF Purple Book 2025)
Nobody said “that’s enough derisking”: The shift to bonds and primarily UK gilts was pronounced and provided Government with cheap money. Then came the rise of buy-ins and buyouts. Bulk Pension Annuities are now a major overhang for the gilts market. Insurers sell gilts to buy global (privately originated) debt – pushing up UK interest costs. So the pension “Gold Standard” being pushed by regulators and life insurers enjoying the benefits of regulatory easing of Solvency II and Solvency UK reducing their business costs caused a fall in UK asset allocations and higher interest costs as gilt issuance was crowded out by annuity policy issuance and gilt sales. A “head in the hands” public policy moment. New approaches are available. Derisking benefitted the gilt market. Equities were considered too risky. UK equities were picked on for disposal. 46% to 5% between 2008 and 2025 holdings. But the gilt market has itself become the victim of derisking with the rise of BPAs issuance. So far £350bn BPAs have resulted in £120bn net sales of UK gilts. Given trends of recent years, at around £50bn of deals would mean by 2035 BPAs would be £950bn and a further £210bn of gilts will have been sold. Total “imposter gilts” from global life insurers would be £1.3 trillion. Approximately two thirds of current gilts in issue. That is some crowding out. Action needed. As said by Torsten, “when the charts are this bad – stop drawing them and start trying to change them. Over to you Torsten. 26Strategic Key Points for Trustees / Sponsors RISKS How likely? Remote Risk to member benefits where there is an investment grade sponsor and a fully funded scheme are low. The uncorrelated risks can be together lower than for the single risk of a life insurer’s solvency: Probabilities of pension scheme falling into PPF: This occurs on the combination of a sponsor becoming insolvent AND its DB scheme not being funded to buyout levels. – In the short term (1 year) the chance of a scheme with a BBB rated sponsor falling into PPF is 0.026% (0.13% x 0.2), or less than 1 in 3000 given a low dependency starting point. – Looking forward 10 years, the chance of that happening is 0.56% (2.78% x 0.2), or 1 in 175 given a low dependency starting point (see PPF entry probability notes below). How much? Reducing steadily Proportion of accrued benefits not covered by Pension Protection Fund (PPF) now modest. It is falling for deferred members as they retire. – Pensioners covered in full up to 2.5% inflation cap. – Deferred 10% reduction for deferred members. N.B. Proposal is for PPF to remove the deferred haircut where schemes have a minimum level of UK investment. Impact of discretion: Endgame gamechanger Discretionary payments can mean members are better off even if scheme subsequently joined PPF. C-Suite has model to calculate what is at risk and how much is needed to cover that risk. – Focus should be on protecting the “real value” of pensions given 5% and 2.5% caps on inflation increases introduced in 1997 and 2005. Safety nets. How secure? PPF is well run with clear processes and has a large surplus. Financial Services Compensation Scheme has little resource and is a sector “agreement to agree” with Bank of England / PRA. FSCS brings political risk not a Government guarantee. PRA states that buy-ins can lose value for policy holders. The “absolute confidence” and “complete security” of life insurer marketing materials is now a stretch. There is no stop loss. BENEFITS How much? 10% plus annual added payments to members link to an allocation of around 0.5% of assets a year. Authorised Payment and surplus use rules incoming in April 2027 make exercising discretion more attractive and practical. Government expects trustees and sponsor to negotiate share of surpluses and phasing of payments. C-Suite has a Surplus Allocation Value Share model. Our model shows that a scheme running an investment strategy around gilts +150bp can pay consistently significant amounts to both sponsor and members. Guardrails can be set leaving a sustained buffer. We would expect life insurers to introduce mechanisms to enable members to share in value over time. CONCLUSION Run-on may now be no more risky than buyout and have a substantial upside for members and sponsors. PPF provides a funded stop loss. FSCS does not. Government can coordinate its regulators and add incentives to link the £1.3 trillion in assets held to meet DB pension liabilities more closely to the Growth Agenda. Policy Proposals to Generate Growth and Protect Real Pension Values
With coordination between regulators and with Government policies supplemented with incentives, the assets behind DB pensions can provide better pensions and stimulate growth. Life insurers and trustees should respond to the opportunities positively. PPF Entry Probabilities Notes Note: Schemes funded at close to buyout levels would be able to secure benefits above those of the PPF – PPF Plus funding level. *S&P Data Source: Default, Transition, and Recovery: 2025 Annual Gl | S&P Global Ratings
|
Archives
October 2026
|
RSS Feed